The state's two leading
voter-registration organizations have called on
Gov. Timothy M. Kaine to delay signing a bill
that would require the eventual replacement of
touch-screen voting machines in Virginia.
The Virginia Electoral
Board Association and the Voter Registrars
Association of Virginia adopted concurrent
resolutions saying the governor should wait to
see what Congress does before taking action.
A spokesman for Kaine
said he has just received copies of the
resolutions.
Under pressure from a
nationwide grassroots movement, the 2007 General
Assembly adopted legislation requiring the
touch-screen machines to be replaced as they
wear out. Critics say the machines do not leave
a verifiable paper trail of how people voted.
Writing for the
electoral board association, Arelia S. Langhorne
of Lynchburg said the touch-screen machines work
well and are popular with the voting public.
Langhorne, chairwoman
of the Lynchburg City Electoral Board, said, "We
believe this legislation is not yet fully formed
and the ramifications not yet fully understood."
Chesterfield registrar
Lawrence C. Haake III, president of the voter
registrars association, said, "There is no
outcry from the majority of voters against the
machines, nor is there empirical data sufficient
to support their discontinued use."
The two associations
asked Kaine to delay the effective date of the
proposed legislation from July 1, 2007, to July
1, 2008.
"This would provide
time for mature reconsideration of the long-term
effects, the potential for conflicts with
impending federal acts and offer the possibility
of achieving much improved legislation for the
citizens of the Commonwealth," Langhorne wrote.
Haake said the governor
should wait and see what Congress does. Congress
is considering legislation to require paper
trails.
The phase-out
legislation would require that when the
touch-screen machines wear out, they be replaced
by optical-scan machines. The optical-scan
machines leave a paper trail to check the
accuracy of the vote. The touch-screen machines
do not.
Because most of the
touch-screen machines are relatively new, it
would be 10 years at the earliest before they
would be totally replaced, election officials
say.
After the Florida
voting fiasco in the 2000 presidential race,
Congress mandated that the old mechanical lever
and punch card voting equipment be replaced with
newer touch-screen or optical-scan machines.
Congress appropriated
billions of dollars to send to the states to buy
the new equipment. Virginia received more than
$30 million.
About two-thirds of the
134 Virginia jurisdictions opted for
touch-screen machines.
"There have been no
reports of failure or malfunction that would
jeopardize an election's outcome," Langhorne
wrote the governor. "Voters and election
officials alike are pleased with the
performance."
"Confidence is high
among our members that use the DRE
[touch-screen] machines that they are accurate,
reliable and efficient," Haake wrote.
Chesterfield, of which Haake is registrar, uses
the optical-scan machines.
The electoral board
association is a voluntary organization. It and
the registrars unanimously adopted the
resolutions at their annual meeting in Hot
Springs on Saturday.
Ivy Main, one of the
critics who has lobbied for a paper trail, said
without a paper trail there is no way to assure
a vote was properly recorded.
Main, policy director
for the New Electoral Reform Alliance for
Virginia, said the electoral board members don't
want to admit they made a mistake when they
chose the touch-screen machines.
"It is long past time
to make sure our vote is secure," she said.
Kaine has until March
26 to decide whether to amend proposed
legislation.